New Evidence of the Two-Phase Learning Dynamics of Neural Networks

Understanding how deep neural networks learn remains a fundamental challenge in modern machine learning. A growing body of evidence suggests that training dynamics undergo a distinct phase transition, yet our understanding of this transition is still incomplete. In this paper, we introduce an interval-wise perspective that compares network states across a time window, revealing two new phenomena that illuminate the two-phase nature of deep learning. i) $\mathbf{\text{The}}\mathbf{\text{Chaos}}\mathbf{\text{Effect.}}$ By injecting an imperceptibly small parameter perturbation at various stages, we show that the response of the network to the perturbation exhibits a transition from chaotic to stable, suggesting there is an early critical period where the network is highly sensitive to initial conditions; ii) $\mathbf{\text{The}}\mathbf{\text{Cone}}\mathbf{\text{Effect.}}$ Tracking the evolution of the empirical Neural Tangent Kernel (eNTK), we find that after this transition point the model’s functional trajectory is confined to a narrow cone-shaped subset: while the kernel continues to change, it gets trapped into a tight angular region. Together, these effects provide a structural, dynamical view of how deep networks transition from sensitive exploration to stable refinement during training.