Closures of 1-tangles and annulus twists

A 1-tangle is a properly embedded arc $\psi$ in an unknotted solid torus $V$ in $S^3$. Attaching an arc $\phi$ in the complementary solid torus $W$ to its endpoints creates a knot $K(\phi )$ called the closure of $\psi$. We show that for a given nontrivial 1-tangle $\psi$ there exist at most two closures that are the unknot. We give a general method for producing nontrivial 1-tangles admitting two distinct closures and show that our construction accounts for all such examples. As an application, we show that if we twist an unknot $q\mathrm{\ne }0$ times around an unknotted sufficiently incompressible annulus intersecting it exactly once, then there is at most one $q$ such that the resulting knot is unknotted and, if there is such, then $q=\pm 1$. With additional work, we also show that the Krebes 1-tangle does not admit an unknot closure. Our key tools are the ``wrapping index’’ which compares how two complementary 1-tangles ${\phi }_1$ and ${\phi }_2$ wrap around $W$, a theorem of the author’s from sutured manifold theory, and theorems of Gabai and Scharlemann concerning band sums.