On the magic of transforming antikaonic nuclear broad quasibound states into narrow intrinsic decaying states

Comments are made on Akaishi, Myint and Yamazaki’s interpretation of antikaonic quasibound nuclear states as generalized Kapur-Peierls decaying states [arXiv:0805.4382]. We argue that these `intrinsic decaying states’ have little to do with low-energy antikaon-nucleon dynamics.