The fluctuations in the number of points on a hyperelliptic curve over a finite field

The number of points on a hyperelliptic curve over a field of $q$ elements may be expressed as $q+1+S$ where $S$ is a certain character sum. We study fluctuations of $S$ as the curve varies over a large family of hyperelliptic curves of genus $g$. For fixed genus and growing $q$, Katz and Sarnak showed that $S\mathrm{/}\sqrt{q}$ is distributed as the trace of a random $2g\times 2g$ unitary symplectic matrix. When the finite field is fixed and the genus grows, we find that the the limiting distribution of $S$ is that of a sum of $q$ independent trinomial random variables taking the values $\pm 1$ with probabilities $1\mathrm{/}2(1+q^{-1})$ and the value 0 with probability $1\mathrm{/}(q+1)$. When both the genus and the finite field grow, we find that $S\mathrm{/}\sqrt{q}$ has a standard Gaussian distribution.