Transposed Triple Products and Pro-Symmetric Rings in $\ast$-Rings

This paper investigates properties concerning transposed triple products in rings. Motivated by Cline’s formula, we characterize symmetric rings by means of group invertible elements and EP elements. We prove that a unital ring $R$ is symmetric if and only if $abc\in R^{\mathrm{♯}}$ implies $acb\in R^{\mathrm{♯}}$ for all $a,b,c\in R$. In particular, we give an answer to the problem posed in \cite[Problem 2.9]{MW1}. An example is provided to illustrate that for a symmetric ring $R$, $abc=e$ does not generally yield $acb=e$. For $\ast$-rings, we introduce the notion of pro-symmetric rings: a ring $R$ is pro-symmetric if $abc\in P(R)$ implies $acb\in P(R)$ for all $a,b,c\in R$. We show that every pro-symmetric ring is symmetric. Several counterexamples are constructed to distinguish these classes of rings, and their mutual inclusion relations are also discussed.